Inside Labour: We’re up the creek and our paddle is fragile

2018-11-04 05:57

There is usually a degree of showmanship when budgets are announced in Parliament.

Former finance minister Trevor Manuel excelled at this, from his multilingual greetings to his populist Tips for Trevor gimmick.

Finance Minister Tito Mboweni followed suit last week, only laying one brief claim to a voter’s opinion – on removing VAT from sanitary pads – having any bearing on the budget.

Although he had only been on the job for a few weeks, this was seen as Mboweni’s medium-term budget statement.

Yet the text was drafted well before he re-entered the political arena.

So apart from perhaps the odd rhetorical flourish, including the welcome wish to see the bloated Cabinet shrunk to a more sensible size, he was stuck with what is the government’s, or at least the Cabinet’s, outlook?

And that outlook, as he made clear, is one of the South African economy – and all of us trying to stay afloat in it – being well and truly up the creek.

But at the same time there was the promise of an investment summit paddle being provided to enable South Africa to power away from a potential vortex of debt and greater devastation.

This summit, as we must all by now be aware, was hosted by that master of the charm offensive President Cyril Ramaphosa.

In terms of rhetoric and enthusiasm he did not disappoint, announcing that the glittering one-day gathering had provided a massive R290 billion injection towards a paddle of economic rejuvenation.

It was all very upbeat, with talk of further pledges of megabillions flowing in from sources such as Saudi Arabia, the Arab states of the Persian Gulf and China.

Although such investors would cream off profits, they would also provide training for new, high-tech jobs.

However, as is invariably the case, the devil is in the detail. The largest pledged investment – $6 billion from Anglo American – is, for example, nothing new.

It is money needed, much of it already committed, to the maintenance and expansion of existing interests.

So the paddle, for a vessel already badly wormed out by corruption, is extremely fragile.

This is inevitable because the government remains mired in the thinking of the 20th century while trying to deal with the realties of a new century and the massive changes this has wrought.

Never mind the Guptas and others staging tender and other raids on the public purse, they are mere smash-and-grab operatives.

Much more insidious is the fact that the government was long ago captured ideologically by what has variously been dubbed the Washington Consensus or neoliberalism, a system that serves the interests of big business.

Trade unions and human rights groups have long maintained that this system has led to the obscene wage and welfare gap, and increased hunger and homelessness in a world of plenty.

They have also become increasingly aware that economic growth does not necessarily translate into jobs, that the digital revolution means that there will in future be fewer and fewer jobs available at any level or any price.

Yet, rather than face reality, most of those profiting from the current system, thinking their own financial lifeboats are assured, are content to blunder on.

Significantly, in the still racialised South African context, two-thirds of the wealthiest 10% of the population is black. Class, not colour, is the real divider.

Perhaps a leaflet circulating as part of a discussion project at a British university sums up the current situation.

It asks: Feeling sad and depressed? Anxious? Worried about the future? Feeling isolated and alone?

You might be suffering from capitalism.

Read News24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining

August 18 2019