Voices

A barrier to Africa Rising

2016-09-02 10:06

The slowdown of the African economy – as a result of declining Chinese demand for raw materials; unsustainable, uneven growth; and the potential Brexit fallout – calls into question the hopeful Africa Rising narrative.

What is holding back Africa’s development and what is being done about it?

To what extent is corruption to blame and is the continent’s 50-year development plan, Agenda 2063, up to the task of tackling it?

The newest Panama Papers revelations, released late last month, have implicated more African countries – 44 out of the 54 countries on the continent use offshore financial structures.

According to Transparency International, in Liberia, seven out of 10 people pay a bribe to access basic healthcare and education, and 75 million people in sub-Saharan Africa paid a bribe in 2015.

Corruption literally takes from the mouths of the poor to enrich those in power.

The recent report of the UN Economic Commission for Africa on Illicit Financial Flows (IFFs), spearheaded by former South African president Thabo Mbeki, clearly illustrates how corruption hamstrings Africa’s development.

IFFs refer to money that is earned, used or transferred illegally.

This can include commercial tax evasion; incorrect trade invoicing and abusive transfer pricing; criminal activities such as drug trading, human trafficking, illegal arms dealing and smuggling; and bribery and theft by corrupt government officials.

According to the UN report, Africa is estimated to have lost in excess of $1 trillion (R14 trillion) in IFFs over the past 50 years.

Likewise, the Panama Papers uncovered how billions have left the continent in questionable circumstances.

Thousands of documents leaked from the Panama-based law firm Mossack Fonseca expose companies and individuals who hold shell companies and offshore accounts to evade tax and sanctions or to conduct corrupt business.

Although offshore accounts are not always used for illegitimate or criminal purposes, corrupt companies and people tend to take advantage of these anonymous company structures.

These leaks have implicated a number of influential, politically connected Africans, including Khulubuse Zuma, nephew of South Africa’s president; former governor of Nigeria’s Delta state James Ibori, who is serving time in prison; and Jaynet Kabila, sister to Democratic Republic of Congo President Joseph Kabila, to name a few.

For example, an estimated $217.7 billion reportedly left Nigeria illegitimately between 1970 and 2008.

Transparency International suggests that corrupt behaviour in the form of nepotism, cronyism and preservation of power are embedded within the country’s social norms.

Academics Wale Adebanwi and Ebenezer Obadare describe Nigeria as a state where prebendalism meant that power, in previous years, was maintained through granting of personal favours and the use of public office for personal gain.

The African Peer Review Mechanism Country Review Report on Nigeria also highlights that “corruption is endemic at all levels of society and has been described as a way of life in Nigeria”.

Former British prime minister David Cameron infamously referred to Nigeria and Afghanistan as “fantastically corrupt countries” ahead of the Anti-Corruption Summit held in London on May 12 2016.

But money that leaves the continent illicitly ultimately ends up somewhere else, and this casts aspersions on the role of the international community in combatting corruption.

For example, some Western countries and so-called tax havens make it possible for companies and individuals to perpetuate corrupt deeds by allowing registration of shell companies or purchasing of property without insisting on beneficiary ownership registration.

A key take-away from the Anti-Corruption Summit was the participants’ pledge to “end the misuse of anonymous companies to hide the proceeds of corruption”, as reported by The Economist.

What are the prospects of an Anti-Corruption Summit in Africa, by the African Union (AU) and African governments?

Prevailing realities demand more action at domestic levels. Nigeria’s President Muhammadu Buhari has been recognised as a warrior against corruption.

Since taking office in May 2015, he has fired senior officials from the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation, arguably the country’s most corrupt industry.

After a biometric investigation, Nigeria’s finance ministry removed more than 23 000 nonexistent workers from the national payroll, saving $82 million a month.

This should create a precedent for African countries. In an effort to find a solution to IFFs, South African Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan called for reinforcement of the law against them, at a high-level conference in Pretoria in July 2016.

Agenda 2063 – the AU’s visionary document for what the continent should look like in 50 years’ time – aspires to a prosperous Africa based on inclusive growth and sustainable development in which the African people have a high standard of living, good quality of life, sound health and wellbeing.

Corruption undermines this vision, and creates and increases poverty and exclusion.

However, the Agenda contains very little mention of anti-corruption plans and action, and no clear strategy as to how this will be achieved or driven, which builds scepticism about the realisation of it.

The call for action is generally too ambitious. For example, it aspires to “silence the guns” in Africa by 2020 – an extremely unlikely prospect in the next four years.

The IFF report and the Panama Papers leaks indicate the staggering amounts that have left the continent illegally, retarding development objectives. Governments should prioritise transparency and accountability.

There need to be more rigorous and robust strategies and practical steps from the AU, coupled with strong political will from its member states, to move towards the prosperous and developed Africa that Agenda 2063 envisions.

A good starting point is for every African government to sign up to and support the global declaration against corruption, adopted at this year’s Anti-Corruption Summit.

Mpungose is a programme officer in the Governance and African Peer Review Mechanism Programme at the SA Institute of International Affairs

TALK TO US

What are your thoughts about corruption and its effect on the African continent?

SMS us on 35697 using the keyword AFRICA. Please include your name and province. SMSes cost R1.50

August 18 2019