Who is an African? | City Press

13 Mar 2016

Dirk Hermann and Mzwanele Manyi

AN AFRICA FOR ALL Soccer star Mark Fish marching against xenophobia. Picture: Solomon Moremong

Is it that Afrikaners are as African today as the soil itself, or does being born in Africa not make you an African? Dirk Hermann and Mzwanele Manyi unpack these lines of thought.

Dirk Hermann

I know Mzwanele Manyi and we have had many arguments, but we have a friendly relationship. Your name used to be Jimmy, and now you’re Mzwanele. You have taken on your African persona – a highly symbolic act.

You might as well, because that is how you define yourself. What you must not do is try to define me. I have my own persona and neither you nor anyone else will define me.

My daughters are the 11th generation in Africa. My ancestor Hans was one of the first free burghers. He turned his back on Europe and came to Africa. Since then, we have chosen Africa. We did not arrive here as people of Africa; we were Dutch, French, German and so on.

We became Afrikaners here in Africa. This is where our identity is embodied.

As we formed a new identity, we took our name from Africa – Afrikaners. Our language is named after the continent – Afrikaans. We can no longer return to what we were.

We moved deeper into Africa, specially to get away from the colonialists. Our trek was for a place in Africa, a place to live and work. Great battles were fought for places in Africa.

In these battles, Sotho, Tswana and Matabele nations were driven out. Cruel atrocities took place. Women and children in particular were captured by King Shaka Zulu, and hundreds of thousands of men were killed.

Within these large trekking movements, we also negotiated for a place – not a place to exploit wealth and export it to a colonial homeland, but a place to stay. There was a treaty, then the murder of Boer leader Piet Retief and brutal slaughters at Bloukrans and Blood River.

We trekked again, away from England; as a nation in Africa we fought the first Anglo-Boer War and defeated a colonial power.

It was not just a battle between two colonial powers. On the one side was a power fighting for the motherland’s prosperity; on the other was a nation in Africa fighting for space.

In the second Anglo-Boer War, our women and children died in concentration camps. My own great-grandmother also died there and my grandmother survived the camp. It was the biggest sacrifice we made for our place in Africa.

Our place is Africa. We have a beautiful European and Western heritage that we brought to Africa, through which the continent has been enriched.

Mzwanele, when I look at the car you drive, the clothes you wear, the food you eat and the language, English, that you use in public, you have embraced some parts of the heritage that we brought with us. As I have become Africa, you have also become something of Europe. There is no such thing as a pure identity.

When Thabo Mbeki was president, he described us as follows in his I Am an African speech: “I am an African ... I am formed of the migrants who left Europe to find a new home on our native land. Whatever their own actions, they remain still part of me ... I am the grandchild who lays fresh flowers on the Boer graves at St Helena and the Bahamas, who sees in the mind’s eye and suffers the suffering of a simple peasant folk, death, concentration camps, destroyed homesteads, a dream in ruins ... I am an African. I am born of the peoples of the continent of Africa.”

Mbeki’s African idea is composed of a variety of identities. There is no master identity with him. There is no expectation of giving up something for the sake of a larger identity.

It is an inclusive Africa.

Within this idea, President Jacob Zuma says about Afrikaners that they do not carry two passports, and are “the only white tribe in a black continent or outside of Europe which is truly African, the Afrikaner”.

For you, Africa is linked to race, but in 1996, at the time of the adoption of the country’s Constitution, Mbeki said: “The Constitution states unequivocally that we refuse to accept that our African identity will be defined on the basis of our race, colour, gender or historical origins.”

We must go beyond race and recognise one another as children of Africa. During my visits to Europe, I saw things that I recognised, but my nostalgia was for Africa – back to the land I can taste; the nature, mountains and sea; the people; the way of doing things; the language I speak; the way I pray and sing – just to who I am.

We are Africa, we can’t go back.

We are Africa, we have no choice.

We are Africa, we are not going anywhere.

We are Africa, because that is what we have become.

Hermann is the general secretary of trade union Solidarity.

Mzwanele Manyi

Dirk Hermann has asked: who is an African? This ought to be a simple discussion – as in, if your looks approximate those of Minister Malusi Gigaba, you are an African, but if they approximate those of Dirk Hermann, you are not an African; you are a Caucasian.

To end the discussion, one should be able to simply quote from the 2007 Strategy and Tactics Document of the ANC, which, within the South African context, has this to say: “African people: The indigenous inhabitants of the country principally composed of the Zulu, Xhosa, Pedi, Sotho, Tswana, Tsonga, Swazi, Venda, Ndebele, Khoi and San.”

If this is not enough, one should be able to source footage from the old South Africa, where this question never arose. Instead, Hermann publicly, proudly and unprovoked, announced himself as a European.

During the Codesa talks to hammer out the terms of a negotiated settlement for democracy in the 1990s, Hermann was vociferous in fighting for self-determination based on what he deemed the exclusive culture of the Afrikaner, and wanted his own piece of land. Indeed, the reconciliatory Madiba bent over backwards, obliged, and Orania was born. The Constitution of the country was doctored to sanitise the wishes of Hermann, a spoilt child.

As recently as in 1998, when then president Nelson Mandela promulgated the Employment Equity Act into law, the various race groups were set out and the term ‘black’ was deemed a generic term that included Africans, coloureds and Indians. Whites were categorised separately. Even then, Hermann never raised an issue.

It is curious that Hermann has now left his potjiekos and travelled all the way from his Orania enclave to ask me the question of why he is not an African. Does this mean he has that short a memory, or does he have an agenda? Does it mean he has forgotten the brief historical developments that I just mapped out based purely on my own memory, or does he have an agenda?

Does it mean Hermann has not read or was not told that in 1652, three ships – Dromedaris, Reijgers and Goede Hoop – arrived at the Cape from the Netherlands and brought his forefathers Jan van Riebeeck et al, who for the very first time set foot on the African continent as grown-up Caucasians, or does he have an agenda?

During the apartheid days, science was used to argue that black people were subhuman, and had smaller brains. Sadly, some still hold this view and blatantly call black people monkeys, but I mustn’t be distracted.

Today we have “Out of Africa”, a concept that seeks to suggest that humanity originated in Africa. This concept is now being milked and mined with a clear intent to rewrite history and seek to deny and neutralise the rightful claim of the indigenous people to their heritage – the beautiful and mineral-rich Africa.

These visitors from the Netherlands today have the audacity and the arrogance to pretend to know our history better than we – the indigenous people of this continent – do. We are now told that, in fact, of the African group, only the Khoisan have a legitimate claim to South Africa. Hermann is now telling me that, in fact, I originate from somewhere in central Africa and that he and I are both new arrivals in South Africa. No Dirk, stop it!

Perhaps, again, it’s a memory problem. Hermann has forgotten that Africans as a whole lived a nomadic life and were moving around the continent in response to various factors, such as seasonality, drought, war, etc.

Perhaps Hermann has also forgotten that, until his forefathers annexed the African continent and put artificial borders in place, Africa was borderless. Africans were roaming around freely in their continent.

Now Dirk Hermann is asking me about my title deed, a European concept, and he now says that if I can’t produce that I therefore can’t claim to be the legitimate owner of my land ... really now, Dirk?

Let me say this to you, Dirk: the fact that I sleep in my bedroom and leave my kitchen vacant does not give you any right to occupy and invade my kitchen as your own. Your question is not genuine; it is loaded.

Your question is cold and calculated to frustrate the prioritisation and acceleration of the socioeconomic development of the African child, who has been ravaged by colonialism and apartheid. Have some honour.

My direct answer: a kitten born in a kennel is not a puppy – so no, you are not an African. You are a Dutch descendant, but indeed a full citizen of South Africa, just like me. Our immediate and urgent project is to use our diversity for a common purpose, to build and consolidate a united nation.

Manyi is president of the Progressive Professionals’ Forum.

TALK TO US

Who can claim to be African?

SMS us on 35697 using the keyword AFRICAN and tell us what you think. Please include your name and province. SMSes cost R1.50

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred

Who we choose to trust can have a profound impact on our lives. Join thousands of devoted South Africans who look to News24 to bring them news they can trust every day. As we celebrate 25 years, become a News24 subscriber as we strive to keep you informed, inspired and empowered.

Join News24 today

Next on City Press

Siyabonga Hadebe | Labour Court’s decision offers hope to South Africans with criminal records

18 Apr

description

username

Show Comments ()